eeriness
faerie
miraculousness
mysteriousness
mystery
numinousness
otherworldliness
preternaturalism
superhumanity
supernaturalism
supernaturality
supernaturalness
supernature
supernormalness
superphysicalness
supersensibleness
supranaturalism
supranature
the occult
the supernatural
the supersensible
transcendentalism
unearthliness
unworldliness
witchery